December 30, 1998
MEETING OF THE PRESIDENT'S COMMISSION TO STUDY CAPITAL BUDGETING
Meeting of Friday, November 13, 1998 (1)
Transcript available. The meeting was transcribed. A copy of
the transcription is available upon request to Dick Emery, the Executive
Director of the Commission.
Introduction.--The meeting was held in the Truman Room of the
White House Conference Center, 726 Jackson Place, NW, Washington DC. Sitting
at the table with the Commissioners was William Dinkelacker, Designated
Federal Official from the Department of the Treasury. Robert Litan, Writer,
was seated at the witness table with Philip R. Dame, OMB. Mr. Dame was
there in place of Dick Emery, Executive Director of the Commission. As
required by the Federal Advisory Committee Act, the meeting had been announced
in the Federal Register, and the meeting was open to the public. Co-chair
Corzine and Commissioners Brittain, Collender, Leone, Metzler, O'Clearicain,
and Rattner were not present for the meeting.
Several items were distributed to the Commission and were available
at the meeting:
-- the November 6, 1998, draft of the Commission's report, which was
prepared by Robert Litan for discussion by the Commission, and Mr. Litan's
cover memo, which identified seven areas for discussion;
-- the fact sheet about the Commission;
Purpose. The purpose of the meeting was to provide guidance to Robert
Litan for his preparation of the next draft of the Commission's report.
-- the Federal Register notice announcing the meeting;
-- the press release announcing the meeting;
-- two items pertaining to the records of the Commission: the November
5, 1998, letter from Marva W. Frazier, National Archives at College Park,
to Bill Dinkelacker; and a list of items to be archived;
-- "Legal Issues/Questions and Others that are Policy, Program or Administrative
Pertaining to the President's Commission to Study Capital Budgeting," a
note distributed by Bill Dinkelacker; and
-- draft minutes of the meeting of Saturday, September 19, 1998.
Discussion. Co-chair Kathleen Brown opened the meeting at 9:10
a.m. and requested approval of the minutes for the meeting of Saturday,
September 19, 1998, in Washington. The Commission approved the minutes.
Ms. Brown announced that the December 4 meeting of the Commission had been
canceled and asked the Commissioners to hold Friday, December 18, for a
possible meeting, if one were necessary. She also announced that the deadline
for the report had slipped to early January, and that January 8, 1999,
was a tentative date for presentation of the report to the National Economic
Discussion of Mr. Litan's draft began about 9:30
a.m. and continued until about noon. The discussion covered the seven areas
identified in Mr. Litan's cover memo and other areas. He agreed to prepare
a revised draft reflecting the day's comments and additional comments he
receives. The revised draft was to be ready for distribution to the Commission
by Monday, November 30, 1998.
Mr. Dinkelacker asked whether the Commission wanted
a CD-rom distributed with every report. The CD-rom would include the final
report, the final website material (testimony, staff papers, and other
information), and the verbatim transcriptions of the meetings. After some
discussion, Mr. Dinkelacker agreed to present alternative options to the
Co-chairs for their review.
On behalf of herself and Mr. Corzine, Ms. Brown thanked
the Commissioners, the staff at OMB and Treasury, and the members of the
public for their support in carrying out the work of the Commission.
The meeting adjourned at 12:02 p.m.
President's Commission to Study Capital
1. Because this was the last
meeting of the Commission, it never met again to approve the minutes. These
minutes were approved by the Executive Director.