| For Immediate Release | June 14, 2000 |
Today, Senate Democratic Leader Daschle, House Democratic Leader Gephardt, and representatives of older Americans, people with disabilities, and pharmacists will stand with the President as he challenges the Republicans to ensure that all seniors can access a real Medicare prescription drug benefit. The President will welcome any effort to assure an affordable prescription drug benefit option for all Medicare beneficiaries, but will underscore that a private insurance drug benefit cannot achieve this outcome. He will say he is open to private insurance options, but only if all seniors have the ability to choose an affordable, defined, fee-for-service drug benefit under Medicare. The President will point out that a private insurance model that does not provide such a Medicare option for all beneficiaries would be nothing more than an empty promise.
PRESIDENT CLINTON AND THE DEMOCRATIC LEADERSHIP AGREE WITH SENIORS’ CONCERNS ABOUT THE REPUBLICAN PLAN. Today, representatives of millions of older Americans and people with disabilities voiced their concern that, according to the sketchy details available, the Republican plan would provide a prescription drug benefit through a flawed Medigap-like model that could not assure Medicare beneficiaries it is available or affordable. The Republican plan appears to:
Fail to assure the availability or stability of drug coverage options. The Republican plan builds on the already-flawed private Medigap insurance market rather than adding a prescription drug benefit to Medicare. The insurance industry itself claims that an insurance model will not work for prescription drug coverage - and that insurers will not voluntarily participate. Even if some insurers do offer coverage, they would likely come in and out of the market, move to profitable market areas, and significantly modify their benefit design from year to year based on prior year’s experience. This would result in the same pull-outs and uncertainty that we see in managed care today.
Provide a private insurance - not a Medicare - benefit. Outpatient prescription drugs would not be part of the Medicare benefits package like doctor or hospital care. Beneficiaries would pay expensive premiums to private Medigap plans rather than to Medicare for an affordable option.
Fails to ensure the affordability of coverage options. Under the Republican plan, it appears that Medicare would not provide a single dollar of direct premium assistance for middle-class Medicare beneficiaries (any senior with income above $12,600). Instead, it relies on a flawed "trickle-down theory" that would end up subsidizing insurers, not seniors. The Republican proposal appears to subsidize insurers for part of the cost for the most expensive enrollees, hoping that this will result in lower premiums for all enrollees. There are no assurances that seniors will see lower premiums as a result. Even if an insurer passed through every dollar of its subsidy, premiums would still be too expensive for many seniors.
Does not guarantee a meaningful benefit. The Republican plan appears to specify only the stop-loss amount. Private insurers could define deductibles, copays and benefit limits, promoting competition on confusion rather than price and quality. In addition, relying on an insurance model where insurers get paid one premium for all enrollees - no matter how sick - and can define the drug benefit puts sicker seniors and people with disabilities at risk of adverse selection. An insurer could discourage seniors with high drug costs from enrolling by offering no deductible, low copays and a low benefit cap that leaves a large gap before the stop-loss kicks in.
Limit choice of drugs and pharmacies. The so-called "choice" model offered by the Republicans appears to break up the pooled purchasing power of seniors, forcing insurers to reduce prices through restrictive formularies and limited choice of pharmacies. While there may be a limited appeals process available to them, beneficiaries are not guaranteed access to off-formulary drugs that their doctor certifies are medically necessary.
PRESIDENT CLINTON WILL CALL ON CONGRESS TO INCLUDE A REAL MEDICARE DRUG BENEFIT. The President will state that he welcomes any effort to provide affordable coverage to all older Americans, but will underscore that a private insurance drug benefit cannot work to achieve this outcome. He will indicate that he is open to private insurance options, but only if all seniors have the ability to choose an affordable, defined, fee-for-service drug benefit under Medicare. The President will point out that a private insurance model that does not provide such a Medicare option would be nothing more than an empty promise.
PRESIDENT CLINTON WILL AGREE WITH AGING, DISABILITY, AND PHARMACIST REPRESENTATIVES REJECTION OF THE REPUBLICAN LEGISLATIVE PROCESS. Amid reports that the final Republican proposal will be released on Friday, marked up on Monday, and sent to the floor for a vote shortly afterwards, advocates for seniors and people with disabilities will reject the partisan legislative process chosen by the House. This process fails to provide older Americans and people with disabilities with the time necessary to adequately evaluate the implications of policies of such great importance to their health. In response to their concerns, the President will call on the Congress to work together in a bipartisan fashion a plan that provides a meaningful and affordable benefit to all beneficiaries.
THE PRESIDENT’S PLAN EXTENDS PRESCRIPTION DRUGS TO ALL MEDICARE BENEFICIARIES. The President will point out that his plan provides an affordable, accessible, prescription drug benefit option to all beneficiaries. It is:
Voluntary. Medicare beneficiaries who now have dependable, affordable coverage would have the option of keeping that coverage
.Accessible to all beneficiaries. Beneficiaries who join the program would pay the same premium and get the same benefit, no matter where they live, through a private, competitively selected benefit manager or, where available, through managed care plans.
Designed to give beneficiaries meaningful protection and bargaining power. A reserve fund in the President’s budget helps Medicare beneficiaries with catastrophic prescription drug costs. The plan also gives beneficiaries bargaining power they now lack by utilizing private prescription drug managers to negotiate discounts that can be extracted from volume purchasing.
Affordable to all beneficiaries and the program. According to CBO, premiums would be $26 per month in 2003. Low-income beneficiaries - below 150 percent of poverty ($17,000 for a couple) - would receive extra help with the cost of premiums; those below 135 percent would have no cost sharing.
Consistent with broader reform. The new, voluntary prescription drug benefit is part of a larger plan to strengthen and modernize Medicare. This plan would make Medicare more competitive and efficient, reduce fraud and out-year cost increases, promote fair payments, and improve preventive benefits in Medicare.
President and First Lady | Vice President and Mrs. Gore
Record of Progress | The Briefing Room
Gateway to Government | Contacting the White House | White House for Kids
White House History | White House Tours | Help
Privacy Statement