Remarks by First Lady Hillary Rodham Clinton
on
Cultural Diversity
Samarkand, Uzbekistan
November 14,,
1997
Thank you so much, Mr. President. You may be assured that I will carry
your warm words and your kind invitation to my husband, who is quite sad that I
have had the opportunity to come to Uzbekistan first. I know that if there is
any way possible, he will want, also, to come and see your beautiful country
and I hope that will come to pass. I want to thank you and Mrs. Karimova for
the very warm and gracious welcome and hospitality that I have received from
you and from your people.
In the last two and a half days, I have met with professional and
business women in Tashkent to talk about what nongovernmental organizations are
doing. I have talked with university students in Tashkent and teenagers in
Bukhara about their questions as they asked me in English with great confidence
in their voices about what was going on in the United States and what I thought
of them and their country. I complimented them because I have met with students
from all over the worldand I say this not because I am here in Samarkand, I
will say it when I return homeI have never met with groups of young people,
young men and young women who were better prepared and asked better questions
than the ones I met with in both Tashkent and Bukhara. I have also had the
opportunity to visit your ancient monuments and I want to thank the people of
Bukhara and Samarkand for opening these monuments for the entire world to
appreciate.
I have been privileged to see the old and the new Uzbekistan. This
morning, Mrs. Karimova and I visited a Jewish synagogue in Bukhara; and there,
the Rabbi of that small and ancient congregation told me of the ways that you,
Mr. President, and your government have restored religious freedom and
encouraged religious and cultural tolerance. Mrs. Karimova explained to me that
under the Soviet Communist regime, individuals and families were forbidden to
exercise their religion, and even prohibited from practicing time-honored
traditions surrounding the birth of a child, a marriage, or the loss of a loved
one. Thankfully those days are over. In Uzbekistan today, people of all
religions can worship freely and openly. As we heard from our first speaker and
from the President, the nationalities that are present in this one city alone
represent the talents and abilities and aspirations of people of so many
different traditions, all of whom are living peacefully in this cultural and
religious heart of Central Asia.
I have come to Samarkand and Uzbekistan on behalf of my husband,
President Clinton, and the American people to reinforce the young but strong
and growing ties between our two countries and to witness firsthand the
important progress you are making as you move toward democracy, create a civil
society, and build an economy that helps all citizens realize their own dreams.
I have come for another reason as well. I have come to learn from you, to learn
from you not only about your rich past and rich culture, but also about the
deeply-rooted traditions of respect for religious and ethnic differences which
have enabled this culture to flourish for so many generations.
In the last days, starting in Tashkent and traveling through Bukhara
here to Samarkand, I have been struck by the beauty of your places of worship.
What has made the sharpest impression on me, however, is their proximity.
Muslims, Christians, and Jews follow their faiths in the same neighborhoods.
Perhaps even more remarkable is that they have done so for centuries. This
spirit of respect extends to all corners of your society. For millennia, people
of different backgrounds have lived together peacefully, and they do so today.
In the school I visited yesterday in Bukhara, there were children sitting in a
circle, asking me questions Uzbeks, Tajiks and Russians. The questions came
fast as their curiosity raced ahead and they wanted to carry on this
conversation for a very long time. I reluctantly had to leave, but I could see
in that group of children the future of this great country. I know that the
people of Uzbekistan have a long-standing commitment to knowledge and learning.
After all, this is the country that invented algebra.
Now, when I was growing up as a young girl and studying algebra in
school, I'm not sure I would have been grateful for the invention of algebra.
But of course, the world advanced because of the scholarship that you had here.
You are blessed by a great artistic and literary tradition. Your literacy rate
is the envy of many countries. I recognize that these are demanding times as
you build your new society and that resources are scarce. I hope, however, that
you will protect your strong system of education for girls as well as boys,
because I know from seeing the faces of the university students and the high
school students that you have such great potential in the minds of your young
people. We know that a strong foundation of education is essential for building
a thriving democracy.
Perhaps your record of finding strength in your diversity does not seem
remarkable to you. As President Karimov told me and repeated again here, he
grew up in Samarkand. He perhaps took for granted the numbers of different
people living together. However, this tradition, this diversity, is rare. For
if you look around the world today, you will see where differences, old and
new, ethnic and religious, are used as a pretext for hatred, violence and
inhumanity, in Bosnia and in Rwanda, in Northern Ireland and in the Middle
East. You will also see places where extremists hijack holy traditions, not to
lift people up closer to God, but to push them apart.
I imagine that the diversity of cultures represented by the caravans
which plied the ancient silk road helped instill this tradition of respect that
has armed you against these darker impulses. Travelers from China, Europe,
India, Byzantium and the Arab world would sit and talk and drink tea together
in the caravansaryan experience which could only deepen the bonds between
individuals. After all, what does trade depend upon? To trade, you must live in
an open society, free from walls and barriers. Information, ideas, goods, and
people must be able to come in and go out. Trade is built on respect. To trade,
you have to believe that someonesomeone who may be unlike yourselfhas something
of worth to offer, and that you, by the same reasoning, have something of equal
value to offer them in return. This basic transaction does more than spark
commerce. It nurtures tolerance, a willingness to at least try to understand
those whose race, heritage or religion might be different from our own.
This openness to ideas led the great philosophers of Islam to
incorporate Western thought into their teachings in the medressas of Bukhara
and Samarkand in the 9th, 10th, and 11th centuries. Their efforts literally
preserved wisdom, like the work of Aristotle, that would otherwise have been
lost to the ages. This openness also made Uzbekistan a safe home for the
world's oldest Jewish community outside the Middle East. It led to the growth
of Naqshbandi Sufism now the largest strain of Sufism. Bukhara is the seat of
that remarkable movement, which respects other traditions, while at the same
time, rejecting extremism. I was very touched and honored when I met the Mullah
at the mosque in Bukhara yesterday. He expressed the hope that echoes that of
President Karimov, that the relations between our two countries will grow
deeper and stronger.
I imagine this openness, which honors many religions, which accepts
people from many different places, is one of the reasons that Samarkand and
Bukhara have survived for more than 2000 years. Despite your great history, I
would not be surprised if your people did not have concerns about the years
that lie ahead. While the architecture of communism lies in rubble, the hard
work of building the new structures of freedom is just beginning. I know, based
on the experience of my own country, which is now the oldest surviving
democracy, that building democracy is a never-ending task that requires the
commitment of all citizens, generation after generation.
From what I know of Uzbekistan and of the other countries of Central
Asia that I have visited, Kazakhstan and Krygyzstan, I have every confidence
that you will succeed. For it must have taken unimaginable courage and
steadfastness to survive under the old order in a system whose goal it was to
stifle difference and erase culture and religion. You held fast, even as the
Iron Curtain cut through the Silk Road. Now that curtain has been torn down,
and the Silk Road thrives again as you travel on your journey, not on camels
but moving toward a new destination, a democracy, and looking toward the
futurelike the traders of old who risked their lives to travel the Silk Road to
new lands and new opportunities as well.
I want you to know that democracy in my country, and in yours, depends
not only on developing institutions that protect individuals and include all
individuals from different backgrounds. It depends not only on holding free and
fair elections, not once but time and time again. It depends not only on
freedom of religion and freedom of expression, but ultimately on whether
democratic values live in the hearts and minds of all citizens. Nurturing these
values, passing them down from generation to generation, is one of the most
challenging tasks for any democracy, particularly a new emerging one like
yours. I am confident that the tradition of respect and tolerance that has
stood this land so well for so many generations prepares you well to face the
challenges that lie ahead.
In a few short years, the bonds between our countries have grown strong
and I trust that they will grow even stronger. We have so much to learn from
each other, and you have much to teach the world about finding strength in
diversity. For centuries, that ancient Silk Road took the people of Central
Asia to new worlds rich in commerce and culture. Today you are traveling this
road again, only this time in a different directiontoward new worlds of freedom
and democracy. Though the journey is hard and the horizon may at times seem
distant, I hope you will take faith from the fact that the President and people
of the United States will walk with you every step of the way. We are proud to
be your friend and your partner on this journey to democracy.
Thank you very much. |
